In a move that has ignited widespread debate about childhood traditions, two New Jersey municipalities have implemented age restrictions on Halloween trick-or-treating, joining a growing national trend of communities attempting to regulate this time-honored custom.
New Jersey’s new normal
Pennsauken, located in Camden County, has maintained a strict policy since 2017 that prohibits children over 14 from participating in trick-or-treating activities. The township’s website explicitly states: “Trick or treating is for kids, not adults. Anyone over the age of 14 cannot go out trick or treating unless you’re acting as a chaperone.” The policy adds a humorous note about chaperones: “And unfortunately, chaperones can’t ask for any candy or treats. They have to wait until they get home to help their kids ‘sort’ the candy.”
Following suit, Upper Deerfield Township in Cumberland County has implemented a similar restriction, though with a lower age threshold of 12 years. Officials note that while the law exists, it serves more as a guideline than a strictly enforced regulation.
National precedent
This regulatory approach to Halloween isn’t unique to New Jersey. Communities across the United States have been implementing similar restrictions since the 1970s. Chesapeake, Virginia, stands as a notable example, having enacted age-limiting legislation in 1970 in response to reports of older teenagers harassing younger children. The city recently modernized its approach in 2019, raising the age limit from 12 to 14 and removing potential jail time penalties.
Public opinion divided
A recent Fairleigh Dickinson University poll of 800 Americans reveals a complex national perspective on the issue:
- 75% of respondents support age restrictions, suggesting kids should stop trick-or-treating around ages 13-14
- 25% oppose any age limitations
- Generation gap: Older respondents favor stricter age limits, while younger Americans support unrestricted participation
- Political divide: Trump supporters are 10% less likely than Harris supporters to favor all-age participation
- LGBTQ+ respondents showed stronger support for removing age restrictions entirely
The survey, conducted between October 8 and and 14 by Braun Research of Princeton, sampled registered voters nationwide, offering a comprehensive look at contemporary attitudes toward this traditional holiday practice.
Implications and impact
These regulations represent a broader societal debate about the evolution of childhood traditions in modern America. While proponents argue the restrictions promote safety and preserve the holiday’s child-centric nature, critics contend they unnecessarily limit teenage participation in a cherished cultural tradition.
As more communities consider similar measures, the discussion continues about finding the right balance between maintaining Halloween’s magical appeal for young children while addressing legitimate safety concerns in contemporary society.