A Missouri woman who survived a brutal kidnapping and shooting testified this week against one of the nine people charged in the horrific 2020 crime. Melissa Pugh, who narrowly escaped with her life, recounted how she played dead under her friend’s body after their captors shot her in the head.
A tragic night of terror in Missouri
The nightmare began in August 2020 in Stotts City, Missouri, when Pugh and her friend Sarah Pasco were accosted by Gary Hunter Jr. and his accomplices. According to testimony, Hunter forced the two women at gunpoint to drive to the home of Christina Knapp, one of the alleged co-conspirators, before transporting them to a wooded area in Miller, Missouri.
The attackers forced Pasco and Pugh to dig their own graves before leading them to an abandoned well. Pasco, 27, was executed with a gunshot to the head, but Pugh managed to survive by concealing herself beneath her friend’s body until the assailants fled. She later escaped the well and called 911, initiating the investigation that led to the capture of all nine suspects.
Courtroom testimony and verdict
This week, Pugh faced Steven Chase Calverley, a 33-year-old Purple Heart recipient and one of the accused, during his trial in Lawrence County. Calverley was the only defendant to stand trial; the others, including ringleader Hunter Jr., accepted plea deals.
“I know God spared my life for a reason,” Pugh said during her testimony, per the Springfield Daily Citizen. “But I don’t understand why none of them tried to help us, especially with Mr Calverley being a war hero.”
Calverley was found guilty of second-degree murder, kidnapping, and related charges. He expressed remorse during sentencing, stating, “I’m not asking you to forgive me, but I want you to know I am sorry.”
The fallout and sentences
Hunter Jr., who orchestrated the crime, pleaded guilty in 2022 to second-degree murder and kidnapping, receiving a 40-year prison sentence. Reports indicate he led a local gang, recruiting eight accomplices for the crime. Christina Knapp and others also pleaded guilty to various charges, including robbery and kidnapping.
The heinous crime, which began as a chance encounter, left an indelible mark on the local community. “It was a very confusing time because you bring one of my babies back to life, then you abuse my other baby,” said Dominique Hackey, father to two victims in related incidents. The case underscores the resilience of survivors like Pugh and the ongoing quest for justice for Pasco and others who suffered at the hands of these perpetrators.
