A former student of Cornell University was sentenced to 21 months in federal prison on Monday for making violent threats against Jewish classmates. The case has garnered significant attention, highlighting the growing tension on college campuses across the United States due to international conflicts.
The case: Anonymous threats post-Hamas attack
Patrick Dai, a 22-year-old who was suspended from the prestigious Ivy League institution in Ithaca, New York, faced charges after posting threats anonymously on an online campus bulletin board. The threats were made three weeks after the October 7 Hamas attack on Israel, an event that has sparked widespread global concern and unrest.
Dai pleaded guilty to one felony count of making threats and was sentenced by District Judge Brenda Sannes in Syracuse. In addition to the 21-month prison term, he will also serve three years of supervised release.
“Terrorized a campus community”: Prosecutors’ statement
Prosecutors were unequivocal in their condemnation of Dai’s actions. “The defendant terrorized a campus community for days and horrified the nation at a very volatile time,” they stated in their sentencing memorandum. The threats made by Dai prompted Cornell University to cancel classes for a day in November, underscoring the gravity of the situation.
Defense claims misguided intent
Dai’s attorney, Lisa Peebles, presented a defense that painted her client as a misguided young man who, despite his actions, harbored pro-Israel sentiments. According to Peebles, Dai is “autistic” and had intended to “highlight Hamas’s genocidal beliefs and garner support for Israel.”
“In a misguided attempt to highlight Hamas’s genocidal beliefs and garner support for Israel,” Peebles argued, Dai “made several posts on a campus-related website in the guise of an anti-Semite Hamas extremist.” She further explained that Dai believed, wrongly, that his posts would provoke a backlash against what he perceived as biased media coverage that favored Hamas and marginalized Israel’s position.
Violent threats spark national attention
The content of Dai’s threats was chilling. According to the Justice Department, Dai threatened to “shoot up 104 West,” a dining hall predominantly frequented by Jewish students, and made explicit threats to “stab” and “slit the throat” of any Jewish males he encountered on campus. The case drew national attention, with U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland highlighting it as an example of the “significant increase in the volume and frequency of threats against Jewish, Muslim, and Arab communities across our country.”
Protests and rising tensions
This incident at Cornell is part of a broader wave of unrest that has swept across college campuses in the United States, particularly in the wake of Israel’s military actions in Gaza. For months, protests have erupted on campuses nationwide, reflecting deep divisions and escalating tensions surrounding the conflict. Dai’s case is a stark reminder of the volatile atmosphere that has taken hold in academic institutions, where international conflicts are increasingly spilling over into student interactions and campus life. As colleges continue to grapple with these challenges, the importance of maintaining safety and fostering constructive dialogue has never been more crucial.