US Pediatricians have been following faulty guidelines relating race to the incidence of urinary infections and infant jaundice for years. The American Academy of Pediatrics announced a new policy on Monday. It will scrutinize all of its guidelines to remove “race-based” medicine and the resulting health inequities.
Doctors are concerned that Black children have been undertreated and overlooked as a result of a re-examination of AAP treatment recommendations. It began before George Floyd’s death in 2020 and intensified afterward, according to Dr. Joseph Wright, lead author of the new policy and chief health equity officer at the University of Maryland’s medical system.
Significant step forward
The influential academy has started removing obsolete recommendations. It plans to review its “entire catalog,” which includes guidelines, educational materials, textbooks, and newsletter pieces, according to Wright.
“We are really being much more rigorous about the ways in which we assess risk for disease and health outcomes,” Wright said. “We do have to hold ourselves accountable in that way. It’s going to require a heavy lift.”
Dr. Brittani James is a family medicine doctor and the medical director of a Chicago health facility. James believes the academy is taking a significant step forward.
“What makes this so monumental is the fact that this is a medical institution and it’s not just words. They’re acting,” James said.
Other major doctor organizations, such as the American Medical Association, have made similar commitments in recent years. It is happening due to civil rights and social justice movements. Scientific evidence demonstrating the importance of socioeconomic influences, genetics, and other biological elements in affecting health also fuelled it.
Last year, the academy retired a guideline calculation based on the unproven idea that Black children faced lower risks than white kids for urinary infections. Prior urinary infections and fevers lasting more than 48 hours, not a race, were the highest risk variables, according to Wright.
This summer, the CDC plans to update its newborn jaundice guidance. It presently implies that various races have higher and lower risks.
Eradicating racism in medicine
The new guideline contains a brief history “of how some of our frequently used clinical aids have come to be — via pseudoscience and racism,” according to Dr. Nia Heard-Garris. Nia is the head of an academy group on minority health and equity. She is also a pediatrician at Chicago’s Lurie Children’s Hospital.
As reported by AP, she claims that these aids have injured patients, regardless of their intent.
“This violates our oath as physicians — to do no harm — and as such should not be used,″ Heard-Garris said.
The new policy, according to Dr. Valerie Walker, newborn care and health equity specialist at Nationwide Children’s Hospital in Columbus, Ohio, is “a critical step” in reducing racial health disparities.
The academy is urging other medical institutions and specialty groups to follow a similar strategy to eradicating racism in medicine, according to the academy.
“We can’t just plug up one leak in a pipe full of holes and expect it to be remedied,” said Heard-Garris. “This statement shines a light for pediatricians and other healthcare providers to find and patch those holes.”