A JPMorgan Chase analyst faced immediate termination after challenging CEO Jamie Dimon’s strict return-to-office (RTO) policy during a town hall meeting, only to have the decision reversed hours later. Nicholas Welch, a tech ops analyst with eight years at the financial giant, voiced his concerns about the mandate, joining many of the firm’s 317,000 employees who were informed on January 10 that hybrid work would end, requiring a full-time return to the office.
Analyst challenges RTO policy
Welch, who is undergoing a divorce and cited the need for flexibility due to family and childcare issues, questioned the necessity of in-office work, noting that his seven-member team operates across different countries and time zones. Addressing Dimon directly, Welch stated, “So all I’m asking is that—I’m not suggesting you rescind such an order—but suggesting it be left up to managers of individual teams themselves on [the] necessity of an office work place.”
Despite applause from coworkers, Dimon swiftly rejected the suggestion. “That’s it?” Dimon retorted, adding, “I’m going to give you a complete answer: There is no chance that I would leave that up to managers.” Dimon further claimed that “the ‘abuse’ that took place was extraordinary,” referencing wasted time during Zoom meetings and a payroll increase of approximately 50,000 employees since the pandemic’s onset. He also dismissed a petition signed by around 1,200 employees to rescind the RTO mandate, declaring, “I don’t care how many people sign that f–king petition”.
Immediate fallout and reversal
Following the meeting, Welch received a text from company Vice President Garrett Monaghan, demanding his immediate presence. Monaghan allegedly told Welch that he’d “just dragged our whole organization through the mud” and instructed him to “go clean off your desk and get the f–k out of here,” according to Fortune.
After Welch left the office, believing he had been fired, he contacted his direct boss, Richard Cundiff, who offered little sympathy. However, later that day, Megan Mead, the company’s global IT support executive director, contacted Welch to inform him that she had “smoothed things over” with Monaghan and that he still had a job. Monaghan also reportedly texted Welch to apologize, stating, “I agree with your message, if not the delivery. We good?”.
JPMorgan’s response
JPMorgan Chase appears to be in damage-control mode, with a representative telling Fortune that Welch was never fired and remains in good standing. “He didn’t say anything wrong in the town hall,” the spokesman said. However, one JPMorgan worker told the outlet, “When a senior member of management yells at you to clean out your desk and leave, I would interpret that as an on-the-spot firing.”
Welch, though relieved to have his job, remains angry about the situation. “I want to do the job that I love in the way that I want to do it,” he said.
Layoffs amidst RTO push
This incident occurs as JPMorgan Chase begins notifying employees of upcoming job cuts as part of its 2025 downsizing efforts. While the bank claims these layoffs represent a small fraction (0.3%) of its total workforce and intends to continue hiring in certain areas, the simultaneous enforcement of the RTO mandate and job cuts has created tension among employees.
